Skip to main content
Recent Posts View all →
  • Constitutional Law

    2,000 Days, Two Landmark Judgments and One Hearing Aid

    In March 2022, the Estonian Supreme Court delivered a fascinating judgment on one of the great questions of European constitutional law: can national constitutional review coexist with the primacy of EU law? The Supreme Court answered yes. Even where EU law already protects an individual, a national constitution may offer additional protection. Why should an individual be deprived of that possibility merely because EU law also applies? It was an attractive proposition and an important contribution to the debate on constitutional pluralism. More fundamental rights protection sounds like something we should all welcome. There was, however, a prison officer behind this constitutional breakthrough. The officer had worked in an Estonian prison for many years and had a hearing impairment. The State decided that the officer could no longer perform the job because the prescribed hearing standard was not met. The fact that a hearing aid might help was legally irrelevant. The officer lost the...

    University of Tartu; Sorainen READ →
  • Environmental Law

    Same Substance, Different Rules: Could “Essential Use” Bring Coherence to EU Chemicals Law?

    European Union law does not regulate a chemical substance uniformly: the conditions governing its market access depend on the product in which it is incorporated and the use for which it is intended. The EU framework comprises over 40 pieces of legislation governing the production and placing on the market of chemicals. Three regimes illustrate this fragmentation and its different market-access models: Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006(“REACH”) for industrial chemicals, Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 for plant protection products (“Pesticides Regulation”) and Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008 for food additives (“Food Additives Regulation”). In this post, I first compare how these regimes control market access (I). I then show that, despite their differences, the three regimes share a substance-by-substance logic whose shortcomings – regrettable substitution and the difficulty of capturing combined exposure – are aggravated by fragmentation (II). Finally, I argue that the concept of “essential...

    Université Paris Sorbonne Nord READ →
  • Environmental Law

    A Toxic Relationship? Antidote v. Commission, and the Court’s Failure to Check the Commission’s Discretion in the Example of Pesticide Regulation

    On 4 November 2026, the General Court (GC) handed down its judgment in the case Antidote Europe v. Commission,1 finding Antidote’s challenge of the Commission’s rejection of its Aarhus Regulation request for internal review of the glyphosate re-approval decision to be partially inadmissible and partially unfounded. This outcome follows a line of unsuccessful internal review request challenges, which reaffirms concerns relating to the effectiveness of the internal review procedure and consequently reinforces arguments on the EU’s violation of not just the Aarhus Convention, but also the access to justice rights under Article 47 CFR. Background: The Aarhus Regulation’s Internal Review Request Antidote Europe v. Commission concerned an annulment action based on Art. 263 TFEU of the Commission’s rejectionof Antidote’s request for internal review under Article 10 of the Aarhus Regulation (AR). The AR’s internal review procedure enables NGOs and members of the public (defined in Art....

    University of Amsterdam READ →
  • Brexit

    De-Europeanising Border Conflicts: Brexit’s Legal Toolkit

    The scrutiny period for the UK–EU Agreement in respect of Gibraltar closed on 22 October 2026, clearing the way for UK ratification. The House of Lords European Affairs Committee had reported the Agreement for the special attention of the House, and peers debated it on 20 October. The European Parliament’s consent is still awaited. Meanwhile the Agreement has been applying provisionally since 15 July 2026 under Article 336(2), and the physical barriers at the frontier with Spain have been coming down. That makes this a good moment to take notice of something that has attracted less attention than it deserves. Brexit created three new external borders of the European Union in places where the border is itself contested: the land border on the island of Ireland, the frontier between Gibraltar and Spain, and the boundary between the UK Sovereign Base Areas in Cyprus (SBAs) and the Republic of Cyprus. In each case, the UK’s EU membership had rendered that border largely invisible. In each...

    University of East Anglia READ →
  • Internal Market

    Caught between proportionality and precaution: the principle of innovation and the principle of non-regression

    In 2020, during von der Leyen’s first term, the European Commission presented the Farm to Fork Strategy. The strategy was largely scrapped in favour of a new Vision for Agriculture and Food, announced in February 2025 during von der Leyen’s second term. The major legislative proposal that followed in December 2025 is largely known as the Food and Feed Safety Omnibus package. EU agri-food lawyers met both strategies with scepticism, showing how the legal community is (largely) divided between technological optimists and technological sceptics. However, the reactions were not purely policy-oriented. They also showed significant legal creativity and reimagination within existing legal rules. One could suspect that this creativity and reimagination supported a particular normative vision of order in the agri-food sector. This would perhaps not be problematic per se, if someone outrightly does not reject certain academic activism. However, it showed how these reimaginations are caught...

    University of Bayreuth / University of Passau READ →
  • Enlargement

    The Commission’s proposed institutional safeguard clause in future enlargement and its compatibility with Articles 7 and 4(2) TEU

    On 6 October 2026, the European Commission published its Communication ‘Preparing for a wider Union’, presenting its recommendations to facilitate the EU’s enlargement. Post-accession, the Commission Communication foresees several safeguard clauses, allowing the Union to address any forms of backsliding in the newest acceded members and to safeguard the integrity of the EU. Next to the sectoral safeguard clauses developed throughout previous enlargement rounds relating to serious economic difficulties, the internal market and the area of justice and home affairs (see e.g. here), the Communication also introduces an ‘institutional safeguard clause’. In essence, the safeguard clause would apply for 15 years from the moment of accession and is intended to address serious breaches of the values in Article 2 TEU or of the principle of sincere cooperation in Article 4(3) TEU. Actions taken under the safeguard clause in relation to such serious breaches must reflect their nature, gravity and...

    Ghent University READ →
  • Asylum and Migration Law

    The Pool and the Pressure: Article 60(3) and the EU Migration Pact’s October Test

    In May 2024, the European Union adopted the Pact on Migration and Asylum, a package of ten legislative acts reorganising arrivals, asylum applications, returns and the distribution of responsibility among Member States. Most began to apply on 12 June 2026. One of the Pact’s central instruments, Regulation (EU) 2024/1351 on asylum and migration management, commonly referred to as the Asylum and Migration Management Regulation (AMMR), replaces the Dublin III Regulation, which determined which Member State must examine an asylum application and regulated transfers to that State. The AMMR places those responsibility rules alongside a permanent solidarity mechanism for countries whose asylum, reception and migration systems face disproportionate pressure. The legislature calls its central instrument the Annual Solidarity Pool: each year, Member States make available relocations, financial contributions and alternative measures such as staff, services, facilities or technical equipment,...

    Geneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights READ →
  • Competition Law

    Collective compliance at the expense of competitive uncertainty?

    For decades, some of the most consistently exciting factual descriptions in competition law have come from cases on anticompetitive agreements covered by Article 101 of the TFEU: combinations of undertakings one would hardly imagine meeting around the same table, sudden price increases by identical percentages, hotel room reservations for regular meetings, handwritten notes and memoranda. At the core of these arrangements are prices and anticipated price increases, sales volumes and market shares, as well as a wide range of “price-setting factors” and pre-pricing communications offering intelligence about prospective quotation prices and trends (e.g. C-286/13 P Dole Food and Dole Fresh Fruit Europe v Commission). The essence of these arrangements is reducing uncertainty over the future conduct of competitors. Competition law prohibits such coordination as it impairs the very independence of market behaviour: each economic operator must determine by itself the policy he intends to...

    University of Copenhagen READ →
  • Data Protection and Digital Governance

    Overlapping GDPR and DMA Competences to Assess Anonymisation: Sincere Cooperation in the Commission’s Google Search Specification Decision

    On 16 July 2026, the Commission adopted a decision specifying Alphabet’s obligations to share Google Search data under Article 6(11) of the Digital Markets Act (DMA). In specifying those obligations under Article 8(2) DMA, the Commission prescribes safeguards and then relies on them to conclude that end users’ data are anonymous for recipients. It thereby shapes the circumstances on which GDPR protection depends, although formal supervisory competences remain with data protection authorities (DPAs). The Commission intervened because it considered Alphabet’s existing offer ineffective, with almost no take-up despite interest from competing search engines (recitals 26-27). Article 6(11) requires access to ranking, query, click and view data on fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms, with personal query, click and view data to be anonymised. The decision combines technical alterations of search data with contractual and organisational safeguards, including prohibitions on...

    Cardinal Stefan Wyszyński University in Warsaw Vrije Universiteit Brussel / Tilburg University READ →
  • Data Protection and Digital Governance

    A Tempting Shortcut: How the Digital Omnibus Would Re-engineer the Legitimate Interest Test for AI

    To be lawful, processing of personal data must rest on one of the six grounds in Article 6 of the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). Among them, Article 6(1)(f), legitimate interest (LI), requires a controller, case by case, to show that it pursues a defined interest, that the processing is necessary to serve it, and that the data subject’s rights do not override it. The Court of Justice (CJEU) treats these conditions as cumulative (see Rīgas satiksme, para 28; M.I.C.M., para 106; and Meta Platforms v Bundeskartellamt, paras 106–112). This test, and the balancing exercise it relies on, has remained largely unaltered from the Data Protection Directive (DPD) to the GDPR. It may now change. Following the Draghi and Letta reports, and aiming to foster AI development, the European Commission proposed the ‘Digital Omnibus’, a package of amendments meant to simplify a number of EU ‘digital’ laws, including the GDPR. Among its many changes, the package would insert a new Article 88c...

    Vrije Universiteit Brussel Tilburg University READ →