Skip to main content
Anubhuti Raje 1 post
  • Internal Market

    Pastiche or Permission? The Court’s Uneasy Test for Artistic Dialogue in Pelham II

    Few disputes have made so much doctrine out of so little sound. The litigation now known as Pelham began with an approximately two-second rhythm sequence taken from Kraftwerk’s Metall auf Metall and used, in looped form, in Sabrina Setlur’s Nur mir. What might once have seemed a provincial quarrel over musical borrowing has, after decades of litigation before German courts, the Bundesverfassungsgericht, and the Court of Justice, become one of the more revealing sites at which EU copyright law confronts the cultural fact of reuse: namely, that art is often made not by standing apart from prior works, but by returning to them, quoting them, distorting them, answering them, and sometimes allowing them to survive in altered form. On 14 April 2026, the Grand Chamber delivered its judgment in CG and YN v. Pelham GmbH and Others (C-590/23) (hereinafter “Pelham II”), interpreting the concept of “pastiche” under Article 5(3)(k) of Directive 2001/29/EC. That provision permits Member States to...

    READ →