Skip to main content
Bastien Le Querrec 1 post
  • Data Protection and Digital Governance

    A complete U-turn in jurisprudence: HADOPI and the future of the CJEU’s authority

    This blogpost only reflects the views of their authors and not the organisations they represent. Introduction In his second Opinion on the HADOPI case (C-470/21) (short for: Haute Autorité pour la diffusion des œuvres et la protection des droits sur internet), the Advocate General Szpunar seemingly suggests that the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) should change its jurisprudence when Member States refuse to apply it. He argues that the CJEU should be “pragmatic” and “nuanced” when national courts fail to implement its case law. This blog post argues that, if followed by the Court, the interpretation proposed by the AG would lead to a severe weakening of the CJEU’s authority and legitimacy, more generally. This would be of great symbolic significance in an already challenging environment for the Court which is faced with increasing defiance of Member States in the field of data protection. The case, brought by the digital rights group, La Quadrature du Net, questions the...