-
Has the Psagot Judgment Become Obsolete?
The interaction between EU law and international law is an intriguing subject. The receptiveness of domestic legal orders vis-à-vis the international legal order is an all-time classic of foreign relations law and of course of even greater interest where the ‘domestic’ legal order in question has itself its roots in international law. That the EU has undergone a constitutional transformation towards a federal entity only adds to the fascination and, one must also say, to the conundrum. Against this backdrop, it is of little surprise that EU external relations scholars love to debate whether the EU is völkerrechtsfreundlich, or maybe not so völkerrechtsfreundlich, or perhaps something in between. The Psagot Judgment: When International Law Meets EU Consumer Law One notable case in which the “duty to observe international law” as proscribed by Article 3(5) TEU played a prominent role was the ECJ’s 2019 Psagot judgment. The Court, in this case, had to decide whether EU consumer law...
University of Graz READ → -
Jurisdiction in CFSP Matters – Conquering the Gallic Village One Case at a Time?
The year is 2022. In a Union based on the rule of law, the entire body of EU legal acts is subject to the review of their conformity with the Treaties as the Union’s basic constitutional charter. Well, not entirely! One small Gallic village called the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP) still holds out against the promise of a complete system of legal remedies and procedures – even after the collapse of the pillar structure more than 12 years ago. And life is not easy for claimants, national courts and EU scholars alike who garrison the Court’s fortified barriers of jurisdiction in search for clarity, coherence and justice. However, two cases currently pending before the ECJ might eventually mark the end of the seemingly indomitable village. The Carve-Out under Siege After the entry into force of the Treaty of Lisbon, the previously existing pillar structure was – at least formally – dismantled. The former second pillar (CFSP) and third pillar (Police and Judicial Co-operation...
University of Graz READ →
Christian Breitler
2 posts
