Skip to main content
Emmanuel Renoud Delarque 1 post
  • Courts of Member States

    Ending constitutional resistance? The CJEU’s rejection of ultra vires review and national identity doctrines

    In its judgment in Commission v Poland (C-448/23), the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) confronted head-on the Polish Constitutional Tribunal’s (PCT) attempts to exert a national constitutional control over the CJEU’s own judgments. First, the CJEU rejected the possibility for Member States to rely on imperatives allegedly deriving from their national constitutional identity to justify deviations from obligations flowing from EU law, thereby reaffirming a restrictive and Union-centred understanding of Article 4(2) TEU. Second, while formally reiterating the principle of conferral, the CJEU denied national authorities—constitutional courts included—the power to assess the validity of acts of the EU institutions on that basis, explicitly ruling out any autonomous ultra vires review at the national level. This judgment goes beyond a mere restatement of the principles of primacy and autonomy of EU law as it constitutes an explicit refutation of two classic constitutional...

    University of Luxembourg READ →