-
C-238/22 LATAM vs C‑180/22 Mensing II: Is the Court’s approach to the relevance of the wording used in EU law provisions too flexible?
It is well-established in the Court’s case-law that the interpretation of a provision of EU law rests on three pillars: Its wording, its context and the wider objective pursued by the rules of which it forms a part (see, for example, C-336/03 easyCar, para 21). However, it is not always clear how they interact, and in particular how priority must be given if the latter two conflict with the former. By looking at two specific cases, namely C-238/22 LATAM and C-180/22 Mensing II, it can be illustrated how this might sometimes lead to unforeseeable results, and potentially irrational distinctions. Background to the cases The legal framework within which LATAM and Mensing II had to be decided was very different: LATAM addresses air passenger rights, while Mensing II is a case concerning Value Added Tax (VAT). Yet, as will become apparent in the course of the next paragraphs, the legal problem of the cases, insofar as the principles of legislative interpretation are concerned, is...
Fabian Barth
1 post
