Skip to main content
Georgios Athanasiou 3 posts
  • Fundamental Rights

    When Values Eclipse Identity: Commission v Hungary (Values of the Union) and the Unfinished Balancing of Articles 2 and 4(2) TEU

    On 21 April 2026, the Court of Justice delivered its long-awaited judgment in C-769/22 Commission v Hungary(Values of the European Union), upholding the Commission’s action on all counts and, for the first time in the history of infringement proceedings, finding a separate violation of Article 2 TEU. The ruling follows a jurisprudential trajectory that was, by 2026, entirely predictable: the conditionality twin-judgments in Hungary v Parliament and Council(C‑156/21) and Poland v Parliament and Council (C‑157/21) had already identified the values of Article 2 TEU as “the very identity of the European Union as a common legal order,” and AG Ćapeta’s Opinion of 5 June 2025 had built an unflinching case for the direct justiciability of that provision. The substantive outcome is, in my view, essentially defensible: a law whose title equates LGBTI+ persons with persons convicted of pedophilia, and which renders an entire minority socially “invisible” cannot credibly be styled as a neutral...

    Antwerp University READ →
  • Citizenship

    Citizenship, Values, and the Rule of Law: The Aftermath of the Commission v Malta Judgment and Article 2 TEU

    The Court’s judgment in Commission v Malta on the Maltese citizenship‑by‑investment (CBI) scheme constitutes a worrying deployment of Article 2 TEU as an all‑purpose corrective that ignores textual limits of Article 20(1) TFEU, interpreted through the prism of Declaration No 2, competence boundaries and institutional balance within the EU. unlimited. By underlying that the EU “is founded on representative democracy, which gives concrete expression to democracy as a value, which is, under Article 2 TEU, one of the values on which the European Union is founded”, that “the exercise by the Member States of their power to lay down the conditions for granting their nationality has consequences for the functioning of the European Union as a common legal order” (para. 89 of the judgment) and that “Union citizenship is based on the common values contained in Article 2 TEU and on the mutual trust between the Member States as regards the fact that none of them is to exercise that power in a way...

    Antwerp University READ →
  • Fundamental Rights

    The Other Side of Article 4(2) TEU?

    In recent years, a worrying trend has been observed in member States’ migration policy: the latter are increasingly invoking national security arguments to justify restrictive measures and refoulement in the area of migration, as the examples of Greece, Poland, and Hungary demonstrate. This development raises serious questions about the safeguarding of the principle of non-refoulement, especially in cases of mass arrivals or the so-called “instrumentalization” of migrants. Moreover, the apparent recent acceptance of this trend by the European Commission is a matter of significant concern. The resurgence of restrictive migration policies at the EU level is not a novel phenomenon. However, what is noteworthy is the invocation of the “essential state functions” clause (Article 4(2) TEU), in conjunction with Article 72 TFEU, which protects “national security” as a new source of justification of deviations on migratory policies. Interestingly, the EU Commission endorses this legal basis...

    Antwerp University READ →