Skip to main content
Gionate Bouché 1 post
  • Data Protection and Digital Governance

    CJEU in second round of privacy dispute by La Quadrature du Net: national authorities get their cake but they have to eat it with cutlery

    The data retention debate is becoming ever-more complex, or so it is written. Since the second La Quadrature du Net (LQDN) installment by the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) on 30 April 2024, it is at least becoming a bit clearer. The CJEU answers preliminary questions on the alignment of national legislation with Directive 2002/58 (the ePrivacy Directive), more specifically concerning the retention of and access to personal traffic data by public authorities for identifying (alleged) copyright infringers. We begin this blog post by outlining the main facts of the case and the questions raised before the CJEU. Secondly, we proceed to unpack the ruling by guiding the reader through the proportionality assessment conducted by the CJEU in light of Art. 52 of the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (CFR). Our aim is to contextualise the present judgment in the CJEU’s line of case law, while highlighting some of the CJEU’s innovations. Facts and legal questions The preliminary...