-
Towards Planet-Proof Computing: Ten Key Elements EU Data Centre Sustainability Policy Should Take Onboard
When we hear digital technologies described as ‘virtual’ or ‘cloud’, it conjures up a feeling of immateriality or weightlessness. Yet this belies the very tangible impact of digital infrastructures on our environment. Data centres, in practice rather faceless warehouses, are the backbone of the digital transformation and have a profound ecological footprint. Across Europe data centres have made headlines over their increasing energy and water consumption, particularly following the advent of AI. Other news stories highlight the gobbling-up of renewable energy sources. The Commission has set a specific goal of ‘highly energy efficient and sustainable data centres by no later than 2030’. Later this year the Commission will submit a report to the European Parliament and to the Council which will assess the feasibility of transition towards a net-zero emission data centres sector. For the first time this report will be based on data reported by data centre operators under the Common Union...
-
Repairing the EU Passenger Name Record Directive: the ECJ’s judgment in Ligue des droits humains (Case C-817/19)
On 21 June 2022, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) handed down its judgment in Ligue des droits humains concerning the Directive 2016/681 on passenger name record data (PNR Directive). This is the second time that the ECJ has appraised the conformity of a PNR system with the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (the Charter). In Opinion 1/15, the Court found the draft PNR Agreement between the EU and Canada to be incompatible with Articles 7, 8, 21 and 52(1) of the Charter. This interpretation cast a shadow on the legality of the PNR Directive as well, as it contains partly identical provisions to the EU-Canada draft PNR Agreement. In Ligue des droits humains, the Court now ‘repairs’ the PNR Directive by means of a Charter-conforming interpretation and, without affecting its validity, significantly modifies the permissible scale and scope of the EU-wide security practice on passengers’ data. This post summarises how the ECJ assesses the validity of the PNR Directive in light of Articles...
University of Amsterdam READ → -
Schrems II and Surveillance: Third Countries’ National Security Powers in the Purview of EU Law
On 16 July 2020 the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) composed as Grand Chamber delivered its landmark ruling Data Protection Commissioner v Facebook Ireland Ltd and Maximillian Schrems (case C-311/18, “Schrems II”). For the background and a discussion of the implications of the ruling for commercial transfers of personal data see the commentaries by Christopher Kuner and Theodore Christakis. The focus of my commentary will be on the aspect that EU law on cross-border transfers of personal data to a third country is not deferential to national security powers of that third country. This judgment is remarkable provided that electronic surveillance conducted by Member States’ intelligence authorities for the purpose of national security is off limits for EU law and that exceptions in international agreement are fairly regularly made for national security. This contribution will deal with the embedded assessment of a third country’s national security powers under the General...
University of Amsterdam READ →
Kristina Irion
3 posts
