Skip to main content
Laurens Ankersmit 56 posts
  • Internal Market

    The Legality of Banning Fossil Advertising

    It is hard to overlook the pervasive influence of advertising that encourages unsustainable behaviour and consumption. As we roam the streets of Amsterdam, every other billboard invites us to escape the drizzling, grey weather for a sunny weekend in Portugal or Spain. This same message infiltrates our many screens, coaxing us with the promise of a few days on the beach, only a few clicks and a low-cost flight away. It is a penetrating, pernicious message whose unmistakable purpose is to shape preferences, steer choices, and subtly create demands. Yet, its impact extends beyond influencing consumer behaviour. Advertising forges assumptions about what is normal and fosters an illusion of limitless possibilities, rendering everything else plain boring. Consequently, advertising hampers cooperative lifestyles that respect climate goals and planetary boundaries. Two years ago, in December 2020, the Amsterdam municipal council voted to ban fossil advertising in public transport spaces, with...

    University of Amsterdam READ →
  • Environmental Law

    Case C-873/19 Deutsche Umwelthilfe: the Aarhus Convention secures enforcement of EU vehicle emission rules before national courts

    In Case C‑873/19 Deutsche Umwelthilfe, the Grand Chamber of the Court of Justice interpreted Article 9 (3) of the Aarhus Convention so as to provide access to justice before national courts for environmental organizations challenging approval of cars fitted with defeat devices. The case is particularly noteworthy for the way the Court approaches the legal effects of international law in the EU’s legal order and the fairly receptive interpretation of the Aarhus Convention (even though it reiterated its stance that Article 9 (3) does not have direct effect). It is also an important precedent for environmental NGOs seeking to enforce EU vehicle emission standards before national courts. The case concerned a preliminary reference brought by a German administrative court in proceedings between Deutsche Umwelthilfe (an environmental NGO) and the German federal Motor Transport Authority, the ‘KBA’. Deutsche Umwelthilfe had challenged the KBA’s decision to approve Volkswagen’s amended...

    READ →
  • External Relations

    Member States Hold all the Necessary Bargaining Power to Decide the Future of the Energy Charter Treaty, Not the European Union

    In the past weeks, several Member States pursued withdrawal from the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT), a multilateral investment treaty to which both the EU and the Member States are party. Some Member States, however, are hesitating because they feared that withdrawal without the EU may have little practical effect for the controversial investor-state-dispute settlement (ISDS) mechanism. We argue that these doubts are not legally justified. As a matter of EU law, the EU cannot hold Member States that have withdrawn liable under EU law as this would go against the internal division of competences. What is more, the EU’s own membership and ability to amend the ECT is legally in doubt as it lacks the necessary competence to assume responsibility for the entirety of the agreement under EU law. The ECT has become more and more controversial due to the impact the agreement’s ISDS provisions have on climate and energy policies of governments. It is the most litigated investment treaty in the...

    University of Amsterdam READ →
  • EU International Trade and Investment Law

    Opinion 1/20 and the modernisation effort of the Energy Charter Treaty

    On 16 June the Court found Belgium’s request for an Opinion pursuant Article 218 (11) TFEU on the compatibility of Article 26 of the ‘modernised’ Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) inadmissible on grounds that it did not have ‘sufficient information’ on its envisaged provisions. Article 26 is the provision that allows foreign investors to have recourse to investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) when their investments are negatively affected by government action in breach of the substantive provisions of the ECT. While the modernisation process did not foresee any changes to Article 26 ECT and at the time of the opinion there was no public information available that parties may do so, the Court speculated that the parties may change their positions and that it therefore did not have ‘sufficient information’. No less than 12 days later, an agreement in principle was reached by the contracting parties of the ECT to amend the ECT that inter alia introduced a so-called disconnection clause (a...

  • External Relations

    Komstroy: the beginning of the end for the Energy Charter Treaty?

    Earlier this month, the Court of Justice handed down its judgment in Komstroy. The judgment was the latest on the relationship between EU law and international investment law following earlier cases such as Achmea (discussed here) and Opinion 1/17 (discussed here) where the Court demarked the limits under which international investment tribunals can legally operate under EU law. Komstroy added explicitly (and rather predictably) that there is no place for intra-EU arbitration proceedings under the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT), a multilateral agreement to which the EU, its Member States (apart from Italy which withdrew in 2016) and third states are parties. Within the EU such disputes must be resolved by the independent judiciary consisting of the EU and Member State courts and not by external quasi-judicial bodies. In the words of the ECJ (para 66): The dispute settlement mechanism in ‘Article 26(2)(c) ECT must be interpreted as not being applicable to disputes between a Member State...

    University of Amsterdam READ →
  • Environmental Law

    Case C-57/16P ClientEarth v Commission: Citizen’s participation in EU decision-making and the Commission’s right of initiative

    In a Grand Chamber ruling of 4 September 2018, the European Court of Justice annulled two decisions of the Commission to refuse access to documents on impact assessment reports in environmental matters. The decision is an important precedent to ensure greater transparency of the EU institutions at the early stages of legislative action – arguably the key stage of influence – and therefore a resounding win for those arguing for greater participation and influence of citizens in the EU legislative process. The judgment’s explicit recognition of this key constitutional EU value of greater participation of its citizens in the EU decision-making process in an access to documents case is therefore without doubt the most notable aspect of the ruling. It marks a major step forward for the utility for citizens of Regulation 1049/2001, especially considering the extensive restrictive case-law (in terms of transparency) in relation to other powers of the Commission under the Treaties. For...

    READ →
  • Internal Market

    AG Wathelet in C-284/16 Achmea: Saving ISDS?

    A few months ago, AG Wathelet delivered a remarkable defence of investor-state dispute settlement (ISDS) in international investment agreements between Member States in his Opinion in C-284/16 Achmea. The case concerned a preliminary reference by a German court (the Federal Court of Justice, or Bundesgerichtshof) regarding the validity of an award rendered by an ISDS tribunal under the Dutch-Slovak bilateral investment treaty (BIT). This monetary award against the Slovak government was the result of the partial reversal of the privatisation of the Slovak health care system. The Opinion is the latest development in the legal controversies surrounding ISDS and EU law after the Micula cases and, of course, the recent Request for an Opinion by Belgium (Opinion 1/17) on the compatibility of CETA with the EU Treaties. Although many aspects of this Opinion merit critical commentary, this post will focus on two issues: the question whether ISDS tribunals set up under intra-EU BITs should be...

  • Environmental Law

    Case C 142/16 Commission v Germany: the Habitats Directive meets ISDS?

    Recently, the ECJ has found Germany in breach of its obligations under the Habitats Directive for authorising the operation of a coal-fired power plant near Hamburg, Germany without an appropriate environmental impact assessment. The case is the latest addition to a series of legal battles surrounding the environmental impact of the plant. On the one hand, the negative environmental impact, in particular for fish species in the Elbe river, has led to litigation opposing the authorisation of the plant, including these infringement proceedings before the ECJ. On the other, Swedish power company Vattenfall has opposed the environmental conditions attached to its water use permit before a national court and before an ISDS tribunal which in its view would make the project ’uneconomical’. This post will discuss the general legal background of the case, the ECJ judgment, and comment on the wider implications of these legal battles for the relationship between investment law and EU law....

    READ →
  • Environmental Law

    Opinion 2/15: Adding some spice to the trade & environment debate

    Opinion 2/15 might keep legal scholars, practitioners, and policy-makers busy for the foreseeable future. Many aspects of the ruling deserve comment and further discussion (see already for starters the blogposts here, here, here, here, here, and here) and I would like to follow up my previous post with some comments on an intriguing paragraph of the Opinion: paragraph 161 on the possible suspension of the agreement for a breach of one of its ‘sustainable development’ provisions. The ECJ’s statements here touch upon a long-standing debate whether labour and environmental provisions in trade and investment agreements should be enforceable. The ECJ found that Parties could indeed (partially) suspend or even terminate the agreement for breaches of such provisions. Practicalities aside, this finding is certainly a positive step from a social and environmental point of view. Background on the trade and environment debate As part of a much wider debate on trade and environmental/labour...

  • External Relations

    Opinion 2/15 and the future of mixity and ISDS

    Opinion 2/15 on the EU’s powers to conclude the EU-Singapore Free Trade Agreement (EUSFTA) delivered Tuesday received considerable attention from the press. This comes as no surprise as the Court’s Opinion has consequences for future EU trade deals such as CETA and potentially a future UK-EU FTA. Despite the fact that the ECJ concluded that the agreement should be concluded jointly with the Member States, the Financial Times jubilantly claimed victory for the European Union, belittling Wallonia in the process. This victory claim calls for three initial comments as there are aspects of the Opinion that might merit a different conclusion. Did the Court just discard the theory of facultative mixity? In its Opinion, the Court found that the EU had exclusive competence over most of the EUSFTA and shared competence over non-direct investment and Investor-State Dispute Settlement (ISDS). Despite the fact that the EU thus enjoyed competence to conclude the EUSFTA, the ECJ came to the...