Skip to main content
Lia Gobiet 2 posts
  • Fundamental Rights

    The Final Episode of a (Never-Ending) Series? CFSP Damages Claims and the ECHR Accession

    It seems to be a never-ending series with countless episodes: the puzzle of the EU’s accession to the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) remains on the EU’s agenda. It continues to be there not least because of the constitutional imperative under Article 6 TEU, which was inserted in the Treaty of Lisbon in 2007. However, finding this missing tile to accession is also crucial to enhance fundamental rights protection more broadly (see for example article by Tobias Lock). This blogpost looks at a specific season of the accession series: the Common Foreign Security Policy (CFSP) area and the CJEU’s jurisdiction. What gave rise to choosing this particular focus is the Court’s judgment on 10 September 2024 in the Joined Cases C‑29/22P and C‑44/22P KS and KD and the preceding Opinion of Advocate General Ćapeta on the matter. The AG underscored that the CJEU’s jurisdiction for damages claims in the CFSP area potentially resolves the EU’s struggles with the ECHR accession (para. 147,...

    READ →
  • Asylum and Migration Law

    Should Temporary stay Temporary? An interpretation of the Temporary Protection Directive in line with its rationale.

    Nearly 4 million people fled Ukraine since the Russian invasion started in February 2022. Within the territory of the EU, those persons who are unable to return enjoy residence rights derived from the Temporary Protection Directive(TPD). As the name of the Directive indicates, any derived right, such as the right to stay, work and receive medical assistance in the EU, are limited in time. The application of the Directive, and the rights thereof, have been prolonged until the 4th of March 2025. What happens after this time ‘runs out’ is for now – in the Directive’s first-time application – up in the air, or rather: up to the EU legislator and the Member States, with the help of creative scholars. The dominant academic opinion, as illustrated by the Meijers Committee report, Asscher’sReport, and a recent post on this blog by Bilousov and Woolrych, is to simply assume that the TPD has a maximum duration of 3 years based on certain provisions of the Directive. This inference is also...

    READ →