-
Paying With Data? The CJEU to Decide What ‘Free’ Really Means
When companies advertise their online services as ‘free’ while collecting and commercially exploiting consumer data, should such advertising be considered as misleading under European consumer law? In September 2025, Germany’s highest jurisdiction in civil matters, the Bundesgerichtshof (BGH), stayed its proceedings and referred this question on the interpretation of the 2005 Unfair Commercial Practices Directive to the CJEU. At first glance, it might seem like a trivial and narrow question. This blog post, however, contextualises and explores the broader significance of the referral – both for the European consumer law framework and for the EU’s ambiguous and, at times, incoherent approach to the regulation of the data economy. While individuals are protected through the fundamental right to data protection (Article 8 CFREU) which rejects the commodification of personal data, the European legal order must simultaneously contend with the economic reality that companies derive...
Vrije Universiteit Brussel READ →
Onntje Hinrichs
1 post
