Skip to main content
Topic: Employment Law 16 posts
  • Employment Law

    The Manufacturable Employee: What Hortis Misses About Remote Work

    The Court of Justice’s July 2026 judgment in Hortis lands squarely on the fault line running through every remote and cross-border hire: does the law that protects a worker follow the place they actually work, or can it be engineered away through the paperwork built around a choice-of-law clause? For a long time the answer leaned toward the worker. This ruling seems to tilt it back. To my mind, it exposes just how ill-suited Article 6 of the Rome Convention is to the realities of remote working arrangements. Here is the point from the judgment that everyone will quote, and the one that deserves more scrutiny than it has had so far; a choice-of-law clause cannot by itself prove that a contract is more closely connected with the chosen country, but the consequences of that choice – where the salary lands, which social security system the worker is enrolled in, which tax authority collects – can. Commentators have mostly read this as a sensible line between form and substance. It ought...

    READ →
  • Employment Law

    The missing social dimension of EU Inc.: labour rights at the margins of the 28th regime

    This post examines how the European Commission’s proposal for an ‘EU Inc.’, framed as a leap in EU competitiveness, exposes structural gaps in labour‑law safeguards, worker participation regimes and equity‑based remuneration. On top of that, its current regulatory design enables regulatory arbitrage and, as a result of all the above, weakens the European social model. The proposal for an EU Inc., presented by the Commission in March 2026, aims to become the cornerstone of the Union’s long‑awaited 28th corporate regime. Its origins lie in the reports issued by Letta (April 2024) and Draghi (September 2024). Both documents identified the European Union’s structural competitiveness gap vis‑à‑vis the United States and China, driven by regulatory fragmentation, the insufficient scale of the internal market and the persistent difficulty of transforming scientific innovation into commercial innovation. These ideas were subsequently taken up by the Commission in its Competitiveness Compass...

    Universidad Nebrija, AP Institute READ →
  • Employment Law

    The Struggle to Uphold Religious Autonomy within EU Anti-Discrimination Law

    ‘Religious autonomy’ captures the idea that religious communities should be free to manage their own affairs in accordance with their beliefs and without interference by the State. Repeatedly, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has recognised that ‘the autonomous existence of religious communities is indispensable for pluralism in a democratic society’ and that religious autonomy is one dimension of the freedom of religion protected by Article 9 of the European Convention of Human Rights (eg Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia, para. 118; Fernández Martínez, para. 127). It is, however, clear that religious autonomy is not unlimited; it may come into conflict with other fundamental rights, such as the right to non-discrimination. This was at the centre of two earlier decisions of the European Union’s Court of Justice (ECJ): Egenberger and IR v JQ. These decisions generated a lively debate: the Court was criticised by some for the restrictions that it placed on religious autonomy,...

    Trinity College Dublin READ →
  • Employment Law

    Cohesion Policy as a Non-Starter: Afterthoughts on the Adequate Minimum Wage Directive and Article 175(3) TFEU (C-19/23)

    A few months have passed since the Court of Justice partially annulled the Adequate Minimum Wage (AMW) Directive. Its judgment (C-19/23) has been widely discussed and analysed from different perspectives. Some commentators have characterized the ruling as a victory for Social Europe, noting that a majority of the Directive’s provisions withstood the Court’s scrutiny. Indeed, the Court only declared two very specific provisions to be in violation of Article 153(5) TFEU. In doing so, it followed a familiar strategy that can be traced back to the 1990s, when it annulled one provision of the Working Time Directive (C-84/94). Other scholars, however, have criticized the judgment, albeit for diverging reasons. Some accuse the Court of having done too little. Emphasizing the principle of conferral and social policy’s shared nature, they posit that default competence in that field ought to remain with the Member States. Others claim that the Court has done too much, striking down the AMW...

    Vrije Universiteit Brussel READ →
  • Employment Law

    The EU legislator walking a tightrope over thin ice: A comment on the AG’s Opinion in C 19/23 Denmark v Parliament and Council

    Most lawyers in the field of European Union law seem to have reached an (unspoken) consensus that breaches of the principle of conferral of powers (Art. 5(2) TEU) either do not occur or can not be successfully challenged before the ECJ anyway. Contrary to this, Advocate General (AG) Emiliou’s Opinion from the 14 January 2025 in Case C‑19/23 Denmark v Parliament and Council – surprisingly unmentioned on the Court’s press release site – argues in remarkably clear language that the Directive on Adequate Minimum Wages exceeds the Union’s competences and, in particular, that the ECJ should not apply an overly narrow interpretation of the relevant exclusion of ‘pay’ from the social policy competences of the Union under Article 153(5) TFEU. He has thus proposed to the ECJ that the Directive should be annulled in full. The purpose of this post is to root AG Emiliou’s Opinion on this specific EU Directive in the broader discussion on a potential ‘competence creep’. In light of this, this post...

    Freie Universität Berlin READ →
  • Employment Law

    Current Pitfalls of Addressing Intersectional Discrimination in the Workplace in EU Law: Hope for the Future?

    The EU’s current approach to – specifically, the CJEU’s interpretation of – intersectional discrimination in the workplace leaves something to be desired for. However, the newly adopted Pay Transparency Directive (Directive 2023/970) is the first piece of EU legislation that makes explicit reference to this legal issue, and thus indicates a potential change in the EU legal landscape. This post aims to provide a critique of the Court of Justice’s restrictive approach to intersectional discrimination claims thus far, and discuss the potential of the Pay Transparency Directive in this field. Individuals may suffer discrimination on several grounds. For example, an individual from a particular ethnic origin who has a disability may suffer from racial discrimination, on one occasion, and may also experience discriminatory treatment based on their disability, on another occasion. This is known as sequential, multiple discrimination. Furthermore, ‘additive’ or ‘compound’ discrimination...

    READ →
  • Employment Law

    Unemployment benefits in the EU: Is Slovenia fighting the good fight or just trying to get away with a free lunch?

    Lately, the Slovenian legislator has been taking bold but somewhat ill-considered steps in the field of social law. Even if bound by the ILO Convention No. 158, the Slovenian Parliament introduced a new cause of dismissal by which an employer can one-sidedly – without an existing business or other genuine reason – terminate a contract of employment if the worker fulfils old-age retirement criteria. The Slovenian Constitutional Court has suspended the use of the said amendment until it reaches a substantive decision in the case put forward by the trade unions. Additionally, the Slovenian government is considering to propose an (anti-)social cap on high wages, relieving high earners from contributory obligations beyond a certain amount of personal income from employment, thus reshaping the well-established notion of vertical solidarity within social insurance groups. Finally, at the time of writing this blog post, the amendment to the Slovenian Market Regulation Act (Zakon o urejanju...

    READ →
  • Employment Law

    Stand-by duties in the Working Time Directive: Window-dressing workers’ rights?

    Showcasing respect for workers’ rights has become a popular advertising strategy. Amazon, for instance, gloated over the heroism of its employees, glossing over the fact that the company’s revenue has skyrocketed during the pandemic. Strikingly, the Court of Justice’s (CJEU) recent judgments in Radiotelevizija Slovenija and Stadt Offenbach am Main mark a similar approach: on the one hand, the Court enunciated the significance of workers’ rights in Union law in the context of the qualification of stand-by duties as ‘working time’ for the purpose of the Working Time Directive. On the other hand, a close examination of these judgments reveals that the Court’s reasoning weakens the position of workers in practice. Whereas the final decision on these matters is delegated to national courts, the CJEU’s guidance in this regard is likely to play out to the detriment of workers. Accordingly, this blog post discusses the repercussions that these recent judgments create for workers. Has the...

    Rijksuniversiteit Groningen READ →
  • Employment Law

    The Commission’s proposal for a European Minimum Wage – another ultra vires challenge for the EU?

    On 3 June 2020, the Commission issued the second phase of the consultation on possible EU action on fair minimum wages. The proposed action reflects the commitment made by the President of the Commission, Ursula von der Leyen to “propose a legal instrument to ensure that every worker in our Union has a fair minimum wage” within the first 100 days of her mandate. The proposal seems to have been favourably received – the European Parliament has indicated that it will support the Commission’s initiative and the European Trade Union Confederation considers that the measures are much needed, not only to repair the damage inflicted by the austerity measures but also to deal with the economic fall out of the Covid-19 pandemic. Commentators have supported the proposals by pointing out the social and economic benefits it would bring, and demonstrating that the EU was taking the ideal of a ‘social Europe’ seriously. While the Nordic Member States expressed concerns about the impact which such...

  • Employment Law

    EU Equality Law: Looking Ahead after 20 Years of Policymaking

    The adoption of the European Pillar of Social Rights (‘the Pillar’) in 2017 and the 20-year anniversary of the entry into force of the Treaty of Amsterdam in 2019 provide an auspicious moment for not only take stock of accomplishments in the field of EU equality law and critically reflect on the past, but also to look forward. The Treaty of Amsterdam expanded the legal base (current Article 19 TFEU) for adopting EU legislation to six new anti-discrimination grounds (race or ethnic origin, religion or belief, disability, age and sexual orientation) and the recent adoption of the Pillar suggests that EU equality law and policy could now be at a pivotal point. In this brief blog post, we reflect on what, in our view, is one of the key current problems of EU equality law, namely, its (in)coherence at different levels (see Figure 1), and whether the Pillar carries the potential to -at least partially- address this issue. In considering (in)coherence, we do not mean to suggest that the...

Older posts → Page 1 of 2