Skip to main content
Topic: Environmental Law 41 posts
  • Environmental Law

    Same Substance, Different Rules: Could “Essential Use” Bring Coherence to EU Chemicals Law?

    European Union law does not regulate a chemical substance uniformly: the conditions governing its market access depend on the product in which it is incorporated and the use for which it is intended. The EU framework comprises over 40 pieces of legislation governing the production and placing on the market of chemicals. Three regimes illustrate this fragmentation and its different market-access models: Regulation (EC) No 1907/2006(“REACH”) for industrial chemicals, Regulation (EC) No 1107/2009 for plant protection products (“Pesticides Regulation”) and Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008 for food additives (“Food Additives Regulation”). In this post, I first compare how these regimes control market access (I). I then show that, despite their differences, the three regimes share a substance-by-substance logic whose shortcomings – regrettable substitution and the difficulty of capturing combined exposure – are aggravated by fragmentation (II). Finally, I argue that the concept of “essential...

    Université Paris Sorbonne Nord READ →
  • Environmental Law

    A Toxic Relationship? Antidote v. Commission, and the Court’s Failure to Check the Commission’s Discretion in the Example of Pesticide Regulation

    On 4 November 2026, the General Court (GC) handed down its judgment in the case Antidote Europe v. Commission,1 finding Antidote’s challenge of the Commission’s rejection of its Aarhus Regulation request for internal review of the glyphosate re-approval decision to be partially inadmissible and partially unfounded. This outcome follows a line of unsuccessful internal review request challenges, which reaffirms concerns relating to the effectiveness of the internal review procedure and consequently reinforces arguments on the EU’s violation of not just the Aarhus Convention, but also the access to justice rights under Article 47 CFR. Background: The Aarhus Regulation’s Internal Review Request Antidote Europe v. Commission concerned an annulment action based on Art. 263 TFEU of the Commission’s rejectionof Antidote’s request for internal review under Article 10 of the Aarhus Regulation (AR). The AR’s internal review procedure enables NGOs and members of the public (defined in Art....

    University of Amsterdam READ →
  • Environmental Law

    Carbon Certificates under a European Legal Framework: Ready for Lift-off?

    Regulation 2024/3012 establishing a Union certification framework for permanent carbon removals, carbon farming and carbon storage in products (hereafter: CRCF Regulation or Regulation) creates a European quality framework for carbon certificates. In this blog post I argue that the CRCF Regulation can pose a risk to the integrity of EU climate policy, as the supervisory powers given to Member States are flawed. Through an examination of a recent Dutch proposal for an implementing act, I illustrate that national implementation cannot repair the inherent flaws of the Regulation. Therefore, for reliable enforcement to be achieved, the Regulation will have to be amended. The current state of carbon certificates and the goals of the CRCF Regulation At present, carbon certificates are issued and traded globally in the private sector largely without regulation. The biggest actors worldwide are Verra and Gold Standard. There are also initiatives for certifying carbon removals within Member...

    Radboud University READ →
  • Environmental Law

    The Juridification of Voluntary Sustainability Standards in EU Trade Agreements and Trade-Adjacent Supply-Chain Regimes

    Since the early 2000s, Voluntary Sustainability Standards (VSS) have developed from niche certification tools into important instruments of global supply chain governance. VSS are non-mandatory public or private schemes that formulate, monitor, and often certify environmental and social requirements across global value chains. Examples include the certification provided by the Marine Stewardship Council (MSC) in the fisheries sector or biofuel sustainability schemes recognised by the European Commission under the Renewable Energy Directive such as the International Sustainability & Carbon Certification EU (ISCC EU). As the EU has sought to integrate sustainability more deeply into trade and trade-adjacent regulation, these schemes have acquired growing legal significance and became increasingly relevant to EU external economic governance. Against this background, this post analyses how EU law incorporates VSS across different legal settings and explains the legal factors that shape...

    University of Siegen READ →
  • Environmental Law

    How credible is the REACH regulation without transparency, quality criteria, assurance, and control?

    The Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH) regulation (EC No 1907/2006) addresses the safe production and use of chemical substances in the European Union (EU). The Regulation obliges manufacturers, importers, and users of chemicals to collect information on chemical substances and assess their risks to humans and the environment, including in industrial processes, workplaces, and daily-life products and articles. It is regarded as one of the strictest regulatory frameworks in the world for the handling and trading of chemicals. The European Chemicals Agency (ECHA) has a legal mandate for implementing the Regulation, which has been described as the most complex legislation in the Union's history. One major weakness in the Regulation is the reliance on arbitrary exposure assessment models recommended by ECHA, a cornerstone of the current chemical safety assessment program. As is shown below, this allows chemical safety assessors to manipulate any...

    University of Helsinki READ →
  • Environmental Law

    Greenpeace Nordic and Others v. Norway: shedding light on the duties of states regarding new fossil fuel extraction

    The production and burning of fossil fuels are the main causes of climate change. According to the IPCC, new fossil fuel extraction is not compatible with the objective of keeping global heating below 1.5°C by 2100, as the associated greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions will exceed the remaining carbon budget. Despite this, fossil fuel-extracting states plan to continue, and even increase, production in the coming decades. For this reason, new extraction projects are increasingly facing legal challenges. Greenpeace Nordic and Others v. Norway, handed down by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) on 28 October 2025, builds on last year’s landmark decision in KlimaSeniorinnen. It concerns the legality of a decision by the Norwegian government to issue new licenses to explore for – but not yet to extract – fossil fuels in the Arctic Ocean. In its judgment, the ECtHR highlights States’ obligations to comprehensively assess the climate impacts of new fossil fuel extraction, as well as its...

    Universiteit Amsterdam READ →
  • Environmental Law

    The EU’s Proposed 2040 Climate Target is Illegal: The European Parliament Must Act Accordingly

    After arduous negotiations, the European Union (EU) is on the verge of adopting a new 2040 climate target. The current proposal would violate the Union’s legal obligations. The European Parliament (EP) must therefore use its democratic mandate to push back, keeping the Union from reneging on its rule of law commitments. Human rights law and international law require that the EU and its Member States meet two obligations: first, stay within their fair share of the 1.5°C global carbon budget that is in line with principles such as common but differentiated responsibilities and respective capabilities (CBDR-RC); and second, pursue their highest possible ambition when cutting emissions and do what is feasible in terms of reducing territorial emissions. The 2040 target is what the EU and its Member States take to COP30 as their nationally determined contribution (NDC). It meets neither their fair share obligation under human rights as determined by the European Court of Human Rights...

    University of Amsterdam University of Amsterdam READ →
  • Environmental Law

    Before Joining, Try Complying: On the EU’s push to join the ECHR and its struggle for a human rights-compliant climate policy

    The EU is currently in the middle of a renewed attempt to join the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR). This move towards accession to the ECHR should primarily be seen as a hopeful sign that the EU remains committed to its values of respect for human rights and the rule of law, even in times where those values are increasingly questioned both within and outside Europe. However, it also offers an opportunity to reassess whether the EU is complying with a key decision from Strasbourg, specifically last-year’s KlimaSeniorinnen judgment, detailing the requirements set by the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) for tackling the (inter)generational challenge of climate change in a human rights-compliant way. A renewed attempt at accession, its likelihood to succeed, and the message it sends The European Commission has recently decided once more to request an opinion from the CJEU regarding the EU’s potential accession to the ECHR. The formal submission of the request is expected...

  • Environmental Law

    Certifying Carbon Farming: (Legally) Fit for Purpose?

    The European Commission differentiates three pathways to achieve climate-resilient and sustainable carbon cycles: decarbonisation, carbon recycling, and carbon removal. Among this last domain, carbon farming (i.e. a set of measures and processes applied by farmers and foresters to enhance the storage of carbon on agricultural land, wetlands, forests or coastal environments) has been put to the front by the Commission as a promising initiative to help achieve the EU’s mitigation goals. Accordingly, the Council recently agreed on a voluntary Certification Framework to promote the implementation of carbon farming projects (together with other carbon removal and storage strategies) among EU farmers and foresters. In this regard, the new Regulation (EU) 2024/3012 seeks to ‘enhance the environmental integrity and transparency [of carbon farming projects] and promote trust in their certification, while reducing the associated administrative costs’. However, several concerns have been raised...

    READ →
  • Environmental Law

    A Safeguarded Green-Deal-Acquis? Environmental Non-Regression as a General Principle of EU Law

    A large part of European conservatives seems poised to hollow out the project that was supposed to be the legacy of their very own Commission President Ursula von der Leyen. However, it will be posited here that their drive is at odds with the European constitutional framework, which should be read as containing a general principle of ‘environmental and climate-political non-regression’. The current backlash against ‘green’ rules In late June, the European Commission announced to revoke its proposal for a ‘Green Claims Directive’, which it had published two years ago with the aim to protect consumers from misleading claims about the environmental impacts of products and services, thus contributing to its broader initiative to move towards a circular economy. The announcement caused some turbulences in Brussels, leading the Commission to (re)reverse course within a matter of days. Nevertheless, the future of the (proposed) Directive seems very much uncertain. To fully understand why...

    READ →
Older posts → Page 1 of 5