Skip to main content
Topic: External Relations 39 posts
  • External Relations

    Omnibus I and the non-regression principle for EU values and objectives

    The Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD), adopted in June 2024, established the European Union (EU)’s first horizontal, risk-based framework obliging large undertakings to identify, prevent, mitigate, and account for adverse human rights and environmental impacts across their operations, subsidiaries, and global value chains. However, within months of the entry into force of the CSDDD, the Commission advanced the Omnibus I package under its competitiveness-driven simplification agenda, comprising two linked proposals: a ‘stop-the-clock’ Directive postponing application dates of the CSDDD, and a substantive amending Directive recalibrating inter alia the CSDDD. The latter was negotiated throughout 2025 and adopted on 24 February 2026. In this submission, we discuss Omnibus I changes to CSDDD through the lens of the constitutional framework of EU values and the objectives of the EU’s external action. In particular, we aim to analyse the implications of a potential...

    Krakow University of Economics READ →
  • External Relations

    The European Peace Facility: A Problem Of Democratic Accountability?

    1. Introduction: breaking the EU’s financial defence taboo The Russian invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 acted as a powerful catalyst in revolutionising the European Union’s traditional approach to the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP) and the Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP), forcing the EU to create and adapt its tools to be more effective in providing military aid. Whereas CFSP and CSDP were previously exclusively oriented towards peacekeeping, there is now a reorientation towards traditional defence and collective self-defence. The European Peace Facility (hereinafter EPF), established in 2021 (before Russia’s full-scale invasion) to manage the military and defence-related aspects of CFSP action, effectively integrated and expanded upon its predecessor, the Athena mechanism. While Athena was limited to the financing of the common costs of EU's own military operations, the EPF’s primary innovation lies in its expanded mandate: it allows the EU to provide...

    READ →
  • External Relations

    The Conditionality Puzzle: Why the EU Is Not Leveraging its Market Power to Enforce Readmission Cooperation

    On 31 January 2023, the Council presidency initiated negotiations with the European Parliament on the revised Generalised Scheme of Preference (GSP). The GSP is a preferential tariff system that provides duty-free access to the European Union (EU) market for least developed countries and reduces customs duties on two-thirds of tariff lines for low- and lower-middle-income countries. The EU is currently revising the scheme to adapt it to current global and economic challenges. Negotiations have proven to be challenging, primarily due to a proposal from the Commission to link the GSP benefits to cooperation on the readmission of a country's own nationals (COM(2021)579, Article 19). MEPs from the Committee on International Trade strongly opposed the proposal, stating that it is unfortunate that the “Council has decided to hijack this trade and development tool and put it to the service of its migration objectives”. Given the Parliament’s firm opposition, it seems probable that the...

    READ →
  • External Relations

    An EU external relations political question doctrine that suffers no human rights exception: Joined cases C-29/22 P and C-44/22 P KS and KD on the Court’s jurisdiction in CFSP matters

    10 September 2024 was a big day for competition lawyers: the Court of Justice delivered two long awaited judgments in mega cases Commission v Ireland (Apple) and Google Shopping, concerning respectively a staggering 13 billion euros of illegal State aid and a 2.4-billion euro fine on Google for abuse of dominant position. Sandwiched between those two heavyweight rulings, the Court pronounced an equally awaited judgment – albeit by the smaller community of external relations lawyers – in the KS and KD v Council case. Commentators expected it to be a landmark judgment, placing significant weight on it to decisively settle the question of the extent of the CJEU’s jurisdiction in matters of Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP). Indeed, the Treaty of Lisbon integrated the CFSP into the constitutional design of the EU, yet it remains a policy area governed by special rules and procedures. Importantly, the CJEU does not enjoy full jurisdiction. Articles 24 TEU and 275 TFEU limit the...

    Université libre de Bruxelles READ →
  • External Relations

    Safeguarding Self-Determination of Western Sahara: All Eyes Set on the General Court

    The situation is Western Sahara has already been addressed by numerous authors (here, here and here) and formed the subject of analysis in a plethora of international forums. Nevertheless, almost five decades have elapsed since the International Court of Justice (ICJ) famously stated in its Western Sahara Advisory Opinion that the people of the Territory must exercise meaningful self-determination ‘through the free and genuine expression’ of their will (para. 162). Not only have the prospects for meaningful self-determination reduced even further in light of the recent shift in French foreign policy, seemingly recognising the sovereignty of Morocco over Western Sahara, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) is itself currently engulfed in another important legal struggle – Joined Cases C-779/21 P, Commission v Front Polisario and C-799/21 P, Council v Front Polisario. The decision of the Court is imminent and will likely have a profound impact on European Union (EU)...

    University of Ljubljana READ →
  • External Relations

    International Law as a Trailblazer for a Gender-Sensitive Refugee System in the EU. The Court of Justice’s ruling in Case C-621/21, Women who are Victims of Domestic Violence

    Is gender-based violence against women a ground for granting refugee protection under international and EU law? The European Court of Justice (ECJ) essentially addressed this question last week in Case C-621/21, Women who are Victims of Domestic Violence. The case was brought by a Turkish woman who was a victim of domestic violence and feared for her life if she had to return to Turkey. She legally arrived in Bulgaria in June 2018 and travelled to a family member in Berlin, where she lodged an application for international protection. In 2019, following a request from the German authorities, the applicant was taken back to Bulgaria where her application for international protection was rejected. In a groundbreaking judgment, the ECJ concluded that women who are exposed to physical and mental violence on account of their gender qualify for refugee status if the conditions set out in the Qualification Directive are fulfilled. This conclusion was reached through an interpretation of EU...

    READ →
  • External Relations

    From C-73/14 to ITLOS Case No. 31: Examining the EU’s representation before International Courts and Tribunals, in light of the Principle of Sincere Cooperation under EU External Relations Law

    On 26 June 2023, the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS) announced that it had received written statements from 31 States Parties and eight intergovernmental organisations with regard to Case No. 31 (Request for an Advisory Opinion submitted by the Commission of Small Island States on Climate Change and International Law). As expected, this included European Union (EU) member states’ submissions. More precisely, from Poland, Germany, Italy, Latvia, France, Portugal and the Netherlands. However, perhaps somewhat surprisingly, the European Commission (EC) also submitted a written statement on behalf of the EU to ITLOS, adding an intriguing dimension to the proceedings. After all, the decision by the EC to submit a written statement revives the discussion on the EU’s representation before International Courts and Tribunals. For that reason, this blogpost aims to assess possible salient aspects regarding the statement submitted by the Commission on behalf of the EU. Does...

    READ →
  • External Relations

    Member States Hold all the Necessary Bargaining Power to Decide the Future of the Energy Charter Treaty, Not the European Union

    In the past weeks, several Member States pursued withdrawal from the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT), a multilateral investment treaty to which both the EU and the Member States are party. Some Member States, however, are hesitating because they feared that withdrawal without the EU may have little practical effect for the controversial investor-state-dispute settlement (ISDS) mechanism. We argue that these doubts are not legally justified. As a matter of EU law, the EU cannot hold Member States that have withdrawn liable under EU law as this would go against the internal division of competences. What is more, the EU’s own membership and ability to amend the ECT is legally in doubt as it lacks the necessary competence to assume responsibility for the entirety of the agreement under EU law. The ECT has become more and more controversial due to the impact the agreement’s ISDS provisions have on climate and energy policies of governments. It is the most litigated investment treaty in the...

    University of Amsterdam READ →
  • External Relations

    Opinion 1/19: no common accord among the Member States required for the Council to conclude a mixed agreement

    On 6 October 2021, the Court of Justice of the EU handed down Opinion 1/19 on the conclusion, on behalf of the EU, of the Council of Europe Convention on preventing and combating violence against women and domestic violence (‘the Istanbul Convention’). In its request for an opinion, the European Parliament had asked the Court three questions: one on the choice of legal basis; another on whether and, if yes, under what conditions, the Council may or even has to split a Council decision to conclude an international agreement into several separate decisions; and a third question on whether it is permissible for the Council to wait for a common accord among the Member States to crystallize before adopting the Council decision to conclude the agreement on behalf of the EU. Opinion 1/19 has already been commented upon: Merijn Chamon has published a blog post summarizing the lengthy Opinion and providing a preliminary analysis of the Court’s answer to all three of the questions, and Gesa...

    READ →
  • External Relations

    Between Security, Secrecy and Scrutiny: Enigmatic External Activities by European Agencies and Bodies in the Fight against Crime

    According to the EU Security Union Strategy 2020-2025, ‘Europeans today face a security landscape in flux, impacted by evolving threats’, such as organised crime and human trafficking. Given the cross-border nature of these threats, the Commission states that a comprehensive response at EU level should include cooperation with third countries, as stability outside the EU is crucial for the EU’s own security. In the field of law enforcement and judicial cooperation this entails that the EU must rely on ‘key partner countries to detect and investigate criminals and terrorists’. In turn, this requires specialised agencies and bodies operating in this policy field – the Area of Freedom, Security and Justice (AFSJ) – to maintain international relations as well in order to achieve their goals. Over the years, these bodies have taken up this task and become increasingly visible on the global scene by collaborating with international partners and performing a wide range of external...

    READ →
Older posts → Page 1 of 4